RSS | Comments | Tell a Friend | Larger Text | Smaller Text | Bookmark and Share

Local News

Friday, March 07, 2008

Man sentenced for fatal stabbing

Robertson for Commissioner - Hancock County - Ohio
By J. STEVEN DILLON

STAFF WRITER

A McComb man, scheduled to go on trial Monday for the stabbing death of a man outside Brandy's night club last summer, admitted his guilt Thursday and was sentenced to at least 15 years in prison.

In an unexpected development, Aaron H. Hernandez, 20, pleaded guilty to the murder of Andrew C. Coleman, 22, of Findlay.

Hancock County Common Pleas Court Judge Reg Routson sentenced him to life in prison for the unclassified felony offense. The defendant, who did not speak at sentencing, will have to serve 15 years before being considered for parole.

Hancock County Prosecutor Mark Miller said Thursday his staff was preparing for trial when Hernandez agreed to a plea bargain.

"We had been talking with his attorney, but it didn't appear that we could get it done," Miller said. "We were surprised that it happened."

The case was resolved after prosecutors agreed to dismiss a tampering with evidence charge. That charge was related to the murder weapon, which was never found.

Authorities say Hernandez used a "butterfly" style knife to stab Coleman, then discarded the weapon.

"I'm pleased for the victim's family," Miller said after the hearing Thursday. "This means they won't have to go through a trial and can have some sense of closure."

Hernandez's attorney, Greg Meyers, the senior assistant state public defender, could not be reached for comment Thursday night.

Had the case gone to trial, the defense had been expected to claim Hernandez, if anything, was guilty of voluntary manslaughter, a less serious offense which carries a maximum 10-year sentence.

But Miller said he had been prepared to introduce evidence that would have proven Hernandez purposely caused the death of Coleman.

"We felt murder was the appropriate charge in this case," Miller said. "If you take a knife and plunge it into somebody's chest in Hancock County and kill them, it's murder."

Hernandez, originally from Texas, had been living with relatives in Leipsic but was also staying at a residence in McComb at times last summer.

Findlay police found him hiding in an attic at the McComb home of his cousin, Jose A. Zamora, several hours after Coleman died early June 8.

Zamora, authorities said, had been with Hernandez and two other friends at Brandy's, and they were among a group of patrons leaving the popular night spot when trouble began around closing time.

Coleman, who Hernandez didn't know, was also leaving the bar.

Miller said Hernandez got into an argument and hit another man just outside the bar, before getting into another confrontation, this time with Coleman.

"It was verbal, apparently nothing physical, at that point," Miller said.

The two separated, according to witnesses, and Hernandez had gotten into a car to leave the parking lot when Coleman and Zamora began to argue outside the car.

Hernandez got out of the vehicle and began fist fighting with Coleman near Glessner Avenue, on the east side of Brandy's.

Hernandez then pulled out a small knife and stabbed Coleman in the upper chest.

Witnesses told police that Coleman fell to his knees. Hernandez ran, dropped the knife, then picked it up and jumped in the car. The vehicle left the area.

Coleman collapsed after suffering a wound which had lacerated his left pulmonary artery. He was pronounced dead a short time later at Blanchard Valley Hospital.

Hernandez was arrested several hours later in McComb and has been held ever since in the Hancock County jail on $500,000 bond.

He had been scheduled to go on trial in October, but the trial was postponed after he attacked his first attorney in court. The state public defender's office was later assigned the case.

Miller said there was never an identity issue in the case — several eyewitnesses described Hernandez as Coleman's killer — but police never got a good explanation why Hernandez stabbed Coleman.

"It's one of those things we really haven't been able to figure out," Miller said. "It's a classic example of a senseless loss of human life."

Contact staff writer J. Steven Dillon at:

(419) 427-8423

Send an e-mail to Steve Dillon

Comment on This Story
NOTE: Comment moderation has been enabled. If you see a comment that violates our Electronic User Agreement, please e-mail webmaster@thecourier.com. Thank you. If you are having problems viewing this Web page, please contact our Internet Department to help us diagnose and correct the problem. We may contact you for more information. Thanks in advance.
Your e-mail address will not be displayed on this website or shared with anyone. It is used by our online editor for contacting purposes.
Comments are moderated by The Courier according to its Electronic User Agreement within one business day. Comments that slander others or include language that violates the agreement will be rejected. All comments that impart opinion and information are welcome.
   NEWS VIDEO

Emotional plea

Nicole R. Peters was sentenced Jan. 30 to 23 years in prison for charges including conspiracy to commit the March murder of Vera Jo Reigle.

  • MORE COURIER VIDEOS
  •    WEEKEND
    Weekend Section

    'THE ART OF LAUGHTER': World's fastest painter and "Last Comic Standing" alum coming to UF on Feb. 8.

    ALSO IN WEEKEND: Groovin' with black history, area young musicians to play crowd favorites, and Tim McGraw calls his latest album his best.

       STAY IN TOUCH
    The Courier on Facebook

       PHOTO GALLERY
    Randy's Seen

    IMAGE BLOG: Go behind the scenes with Courier photographer Randy Roberts.


    You can purchase photographs from The Courier through our easy-to-use online system. Get prints, mousepads, T-shirts and more!

      LATEST COMMENTS Last 10 comments submitted by our readers...
    Nina Parker wrote in article "Thumbs":
    Thumbs up for the Black Heritage Library & Multicultural Center
    “ Thank you so much for noting The Library's Grand Re-Opening!! Your thumbs up and compliment meant a lot to me!!! Mr. Heminger... ” Read More...
    cry me a river
    “ If you don't work at Cooper how do you know the scabs are hard workers, and to give you a little of your own advise. If you don'... ” Read More...
    Marlene wrote in article "Kucinich to meet with Cooper union":
    Police & fire
    “ Observer -- Yes.... but it's still a form of socialism, darling!

    Since these loudmouths who've been trolling on here claim to...
    ” Read More...
    lovinwife wrote in article "Kucinich to meet with Cooper union":
    wonderful time in Florida
    “ you are an idiot...Max unemployment is less than $500 and it isn't $200 a week in gift cards and they aren't makin all of your c... ” Read More...
    The more things change...
    “ ...the more they stay the same.

    Remember the 2004 trip our old Mayor Spendsalot took on the taxpayer dime to Japan and Taiwa...
    ” Read More...
    Dan Merkle wrote in article "Kucinich to meet with Cooper union":
    Another Democrat
    “ . "The workers at Cooper have shown great courage and fortitude."
    Should read, . "The workers at Cooper have shown great stupid...
    ” Read More...
    Kenny Powers wrote in article "Public Record":
    Bob
    “ You are correct, If the driver was 21 or older and he got pulled over for speeding but only blew a .053. That means he was under... ” Read More...
    Ben L wrote in article "Kucinich to meet with Cooper union":
    Barrel Basher
    “ Yep, you "figured" wrong again. But that seems to be the norm with you. I find it disturbing that a person from corporate would... ” Read More...
    T-Mark wrote in article "Kucinich to meet with Cooper union":
    I'm amazed...
    “ at the ability and talent of some of the people that post here. It would appear that some people are able to determine if you a... ” Read More...
    bornandbreed wrote in article "Regional leaders traveling to Japan":
    Mihalik
    “ Thinks she is so important that she will impress Japan by her presence? She is having trouble impressing the voters of Findlay.... ” Read More...
      U.S. Headlines
      World News
      Ohio News
    CourierBridal: 28th Wedding Showcase 2012!
    News Briefs Fire destroys Mount Blanchard home
    MOUNT BLANCHARD -- A rural Mount Blanchard home was destroyed by fire Friday.

    The blaze struck a single-family residence on Delaware Township 149 at about 7 a.m., said Phyllis Davis with the Hancock County Red Cross Disaster Action Team.

    Firefighters said the fire may have been caused by an electrical problem in the older house, Davis said.

    No one was injured and the family is staying with friends, she said. The Red Cross provided food and clothing to the family, she said.

    Additional details about the fire were not available Friday night.


    Motorist cited after hitting train
    MORTIMER -- A Van Buren woman drove a pickup truck into a stopped train and was cited for operating a vehicle while intoxicated early Friday, authorities say.

    Autumn Miller, 31, of Van Buren, was driving north on Hancock County 220, near Hancock 216 in Allen Township, at 1:46 a.m. when she failed to yield to a stopped train on the tracks, according to Hancock County Sheriff's Deputy Mike DeVore.

    Miller's 1997 Dodge Dakota pickup hit a lowered, lit crossbar and a stationary coal car, according to DeVore.

    Employees of Norfolk Southern Railroad were unaware the train car was damaged until a later stop, according to DeVore.

    Miller declined medical treatment, according to DeVore.

    She was cited for failing to maintain an assured clear distance ahead, and was taken into custody for operating a vehicle while intoxicated, according to DeVore.

    The pickup was towed by Dick's Towing.


    Photo exhibition to open Sunday
    BLUFFTON -- An exhibition of black and white photography, titled "Gray Space: Windows from the Ordinary into the Extraordinary," will open Sunday in the Grace Albrecht Gallery of Bluffton University's Sauder Visual Arts Center.

    Photography by international and American artists will be included in the exhibit, which will continue through March 2.

    The gallery is open from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. weekdays and 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. Saturdays and Sundays.

    The work of Findlay native and visiting artist Craig Line, now a Vermont resident, will be part of the exhibit. He has worked for "Vermont Magazine" and will present a talk at 6 p.m. Feb. 14 in the arts center's Hester Lecture Hall.

    Another Findlay native, Roger Sugden, now a resident of Fort Wayne, as well as Findlay artists Spencer Cunningham and Danny Gantchev will also have work included in the exhibition.


    Absentee ballots available in Tiffin
    TIFFIN -- Absentee ballots for the March 6 primary are available at the Seneca County Board of Elections, 71 S. Washington St., Tiffin. Absentee voting can be done at the board of elections offices, too.

    Ballots can be mailed if an application, signed by the voter, is sent to the office. Applications by mail must be returned by noon March 3. To request an application, call the office at 419-447-4424.


    Clarification
    Also traveling to Japan today to advance economic development are John Haywood, president and CEO of the Findlay-Hancock County Alliance; Tim Mayle, assistant director, Findlay-Hancock County Economic Development; Dennis Hellmann, director of external affairs for AT&T; and Paul Zito, vice president of international development for JobsOhio. A story about the trade mission appeared Friday.