RSS | Comments | Tell a Friend | Larger Text | Smaller Text | Bookmark and Share

Local News

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Official's dual roles raising questions
By LOU WILIN

STAFF WRITER

An economic development official's new positions with both the Blanchard Valley Port Authority and GreaterFindlayInc. could be a conflict of interest, according to ethics experts.

When a person has a conflict of interest, he is serving two different principles or interests and may be unable to serve at least one satisfactorily, said Buie Seawell, chairman of the Business Ethics and Legal Studies Department at the University of Denver's Daniels College of Business.

Eric Phillips will be a public employee when he becomes vice president of the Blanchard Valley Port Authority on Sept. 4. The port authority was formed recently to offer financing for economic development.

As authority vice president, Phillips will develop economic prospects for financing and will be a liaison to GreaterFindlayInc.

Also on Sept. 4, Phillips will become president of GreaterFindlayInc., a private nonprofit corporation which also advances economic development.

As president, he will be an advocate for parties seeking financing will be $96,000 per year, but all of it will come indirectly from GreaterFindlay.

The port authority will only be able to pay Phillips with money it receives from GreaterFindlay. It has no other revenue source.

GreaterFindlay is not disclosing what it will pay Phillips as its president. The previous president, Doug Peters, was paid $141,206 in salary and $17,255 in benefits in 2006, according to a federal tax return filed by GreaterFindlay. Peters had no other jobs while at GreaterFindlay.

Port Authority and GreaterFindlay officials say there is no conflict of interest in the two positions.

But Seawell called the arrangement with Phillips "peculiar."

"You don't pay public officials with private money to perform public duties," he said. "(Phillips') master in this situation is (GreaterFindlay), but his authority is in the port authority."

Ohio's ethics law requires a public employee to be paid only by his public employer for his public duties, said David Freel, executive director of the state Ethics Commission.

He declined to comment on the specifics of the port authority-GreaterFindlay case. But the law's intent is that only the public should be paying the public employee, he said.

The idea of the law: "If (the job) is going to be done on behalf of the public, then the public has control through their expenditure of money over how the public will is going to be accomplished," Freel said.

"You can't serve dual employers, because your allegiance is conflicted," Freel said.

The ethics commission can advise government officials. It also investigates allegations against public officials. It had 131 cases on its docket last year.

Phillips' GreaterFindlay job could undermine his objectivity in developing prospects for port authority financing, said Jennifer Hardin, chief advisory attorney for the state Ethics Commission.

"Where two entities are closely related or act together, the possibility for conflict may be significant and the officer would have to be careful about it," Hardin said.

In fact, Ohio law prohibits public employees from having a business relationship with a party having a matter before their public employer unless they abstain from that matter.

"He should tread lightly in anything that would affect (GreaterFindlay)," said Michael Rich, assistant law professor at Capital University in Columbus.

Port Authority Board Chairman Robert Beach said if a conflict would arise, Phillips would have to abstain.

But it also is clear port authority and GreaterFindlay leaders want Phillips in the thick of things between them, not abstaining.

"The port authority is expecting things out of (GreaterFindlay) and in return, (GreaterFindlay) is expecting things out of the port authority," authority President Jerry Arkebauer said.

Arkebauer has not been paid yet by the port authority. He will be paid from fees the port authority collects on its financing deals.

GreaterFindlay Board Chairman Randy Lohoff said with Phillips in the dual roles, deals will be completed more swiftly and more often.

All three said they see no conflict.

"I don't see anything that would be remotely a conflict," Beach said.

Lohoff said, "There is no inherent conflict of interest between (GreaterFindlay) and the port authority ... I can't think of an instance where their interests would vary."

Seawell was not convinced.

"Maybe they believe the interest of (GreaterFindlay) is the public's interest," Seawell said.

He laughed. Phillips did not.

Phillips said his dual roles will sharpen communication and cooperation between the agencies.

"When it (economic development) works well, everyone has the same playbook," he said.

"When government and the private sector don't have a strong partnership, it is harder to resolve issues," Phillips said. "The big tie is so important. There has to be a partnership. You have to roll up your sleeves and work together."

But Seawell said it is the very efficiency of the arrangement that will pose conflicts for Phillips.

In private business, efficiency "is everything," but in government and public business, it "is not everything," he said.

"Government is set up so we break up power, so no special interests can take it over," Seawell said.

"Business aggregates power. Government diffuses power because the interests of the public are so diffuse," he said.

"Both (business and government) are legitimate interests, but they have a tension," Seawell said. "The purpose of business is to make money for the shareholders. The purpose of government is to maintain the public trust and serve the public welfare."

Even if Phillips navigates the differing demands well, Seawell said, there could be problems with public confidence.

"He has got to be pure as the driven snow and have the same integrity as the pope," Seawell said.

Phillips will have to be so circumspect that GreaterFindlay members might wonder if he can completely serve them.

"His decisions can be challenged just because of the appearance of a conflict," Seawell said. "This is going to be a constant nuisance to the system."

"It is not illegal, and not necessarily unethical," he said. "It is just not wise."

Wilin: 419-427-8413,

Send an e-mail to Lou Wilin
Comment on This Story
NOTE: Comment moderation has been enabled. If you see a comment that violates our Electronic User Agreement, please e-mail rebeccaconklin@thecourier.com. Thank you. If you are having problems viewing this Web page, please contact our Internet Department to help us diagnose and correct the problem. We may contact you for more information. Thanks in advance.
Your e-mail address will not be displayed on this website or shared with anyone. It is used by our online editor for contacting purposes.
Comments are moderated by The Courier according to its Electronic User Agreement within one business day. Comments that slander others or include language that violates the agreement will be rejected. All comments that impart opinion and information are welcome.

2 Comments

Latest comments listed first.
Sue Ellen wrote:
Crooked GFI
“ GFI is turning crooked. They spent all their time bringing in someone from out of town. Then the guy just wanted to stay a government worker. He wanted to keep his pension with the Public Employees Retirement. That is why this whole mess happened. They had to get his pay to a public office so he could collect his pension. Crooked crooked. What other things have GFI been doing that should be looked at? ”
Saturday, August 23, 2008 11:07:11 PM
JAMES wrote:
CHANGE
“ This seems to be going on a lot around here
Conflict of interest heres one more example of it
K.C.Collete third ward councilman and also works for the county prosecutors office .
Can this give someone a clear mind on when it comes rulings for the people of this city, the bottom line its just not right ,,,,.and its time to do something about it .. ”
Saturday, August 23, 2008 7:14:15 AM
   VIDEO
Little Rock Nine

LITTLE ROCK NINE: Jefferson Thomas, who was among nine black students initially barred by the Arkansas governor from attending Little Rock Central High School in 1957, spoke to Findlay students as part of Black History Month. The crisis was a pivotal moment in the struggle for civil rights.


   SPECIAL SECTIONS
BRIDAL TAB

WINTER BRIDAL TAB: Dove releases, prenuptial agreements, bridesmaid advice, budget tips and more to plan your big day.


Brought to you by


ARY DJ
   STAY IN TOUCH
The Courier on Facebook
   VIRTUAL VILLAGE
What's Cookin'

FOLD IT IN: Swap recipes and learn kitchen tricks with community blogger Paula Gossman.


Far Flung Guest Book

DROP A LINE: Whether you're always here or just passing through, visit and sign our online Guest Book on the Far Flung blog.


Virtual Village
   PHOTO GALLERY
Randy's Seen

IMAGE BLOG: Go behind the scenes with Courier photographer Randy Roberts.


You can purchase photographs from The Courier through our easy-to-use online system. Get prints, mousepads, T-shirts and more!

   LOCAL NEWS
  LATEST COMMENTS Last 10 comments submitted by our readers...
Holly wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
Snow Snow Snow!!!
“ Why should I be the one who gets a ticket when at my job I have to go in no matter the level? Sat when it was a level 3 I had to... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 3:52:55 PM
Mark wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
Snow, snow and more snow
“ We should all know by now, it's going to snow, but you know, people still want to go when we all know we better not go. ” Read More...
2/9/2010 2:47:48 PM
tim wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
Kyle....It's another story
“ This was definately a City of Findlay plow. Just wondering.... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 2:45:32 PM
A wrote in article "Sheriff reminds motorists of road level advisories":
Thank You!
“ I would like to thank all those involved in the city and county who are trying very hard to make the best of a bad storm. Yes,... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 2:36:10 PM
Understanding wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
snow
“ I don't think the woman who complained that "too much snow had been piled at the end of her street, blocking her view" was in th... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 2:28:17 PM
Kyle wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
To Tim
“ It's a very good possibility that a plow with it's blade up was not a City of Findlay plow. Many people have their own plows and... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 1:17:57 PM
HLB wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
That's really sad...
“ You know, people are rude enough most of the time in this city and this last storm when random folks pulled together and I saw t... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 12:32:18 PM
rob wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
pile of snow
“ I cannot believe someone would call up and complain that a pile of snnow was blocking their view. What is this world coming to.... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 11:38:49 AM
tim wrote in article "Officials say stuck cars may be towed":
put the blades down this time
“ Can someone please tell me why I see and saw several snowplows driving down streets that needed plowed with the blades up? ” Read More...
2/9/2010 10:39:25 AM
Jimbo wrote in article "Sheriff reminds motorists of road level advisories":
To Debbie..
“ I want to express that I understand where you are going with your post, but be practical. If a level 3 is called, that means no... ” Read More...
2/9/2010 10:35:28 AM
  U.S. Headlines
  World News
  Ohio News
News Briefs D.C. trip delayed
A trip to Washington, D.C. that Findlay and Ottawa officials were planning to make this week has been postponed because of the inclement weather.

Findlay Mayor Pete Sehnert said officials have rescheduled the trip for Feb. 23 to meet with a lobbying group and congressional representatives regarding federal spending on flood control projects.

Fostoria requires clearing sidewalks
FOSTORIA -- Fostoria residents are responsible for removing snow and ice from sidewalks within 12 hours of a storm, according to police Capt. Patrick Brooks.

The city code covers residential owners or tenants, and business owners of properties which abut a sidewalk.

An offense is a minor misdemeanor, with a fine of up to $100. Each day constitutes a separate offense.

Library in Forest reschedules event
FOREST -- Because of the expected inclement weather, the Forest-Jackson Public Library has rescheduled its Valentine luncheon planned for Thursday to 11:30 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 18.

Reservations are required. Anyone with questions can call the library at 419-273-2400.

Disc golf tourney set for Saturday
The Ray Heverling Charity Ice Bowl Tournament has been rescheduled for 1 p.m. Saturday at Riverbend Recreation Area, off Ohio 568 east of Findlay.

Registration begins at noon.

The tournament was canceled last Saturday because of a snowstorm.

The Disc Golf Community Association, in cooperation with the Hancock Park District, sponsors the event. Proceeds go to the Family Center of Findlay-Hancock County.

For more information contact Nathan Buck at p_nate@thecatalystcc.com or 419-306-7405. Entry fee is $20. Additional donations are accepted.

Housing Authority meeting postponed
Because of an expected winter storm this week, the Hancock Metropolitan Housing Authority has canceled its regular board meeting scheduled for Thursday. It will be held at 8 a.m. Thursday, Feb. 18 at the Family Center.

Fostoria library to close Monday
FOSTORIA -- Kaubisch Memorial Public Library will be closed Monday, Feb. 15, in observance of Presidents Day.

Crime Of The Week
Findlay/Hancock County Crime Stoppers is looking for information about a break-in at the Arlington Pharmacy, 200 Main St., at 12:51 a.m. Dec. 28.

A glass pane in the front door of the business was shattered, and entry was made. Once inside, the perpetrators took prescription medications and fled on foot.

Two white males were seen running from the business. The males were possibly in their late teens to early 20s, and possibly entered a vehicle.

People with information about this or any other crime that would lead to an arrest or indictment will be eligible for a cash reward of up to $1,000.

Crime Stoppers can be called weekdays from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. at 419-425-TIPS or 419-425-8477. Callers can remain anonymous.

The Web site is www.hancockcrimestoppers.org.